So, I hadn’t seen it before. That day, 10 years ago, I was in a classroom, and was told not to share what was going on with students because these Chicagoans had parents working for United Airlines and we didn’t want to scare those students. The only thing we knew came from an announcement and prayer from Mr. Sander, that it appeared we were under attack.
It was a difficult day. Trying to talk about grammar and follow lesson plans when all along, I knew something destructive and threatening was going on. Something that, that day, was changing our world forever. I had a brother in the Army, newly stationed in Kuwait. I had students asking me questions, questions for which I had no answer. Literally. I didn’t know what was going on because we were supposed to work, teach, learn as usual. I didn’t know how I was supposed to live and teach, all at the same time.
Tonight, during the Vikings halftime, I found myself riveted to MSNBC, their coverage from that day, as it happened. I hadn’t seen it before. Before this afternoon, I had turned the channel whenever a mention of 9/11 came up. My heart not prepared, my mind not ready to relive those moments of uncertainty and confusion.
10 years ago, during my prep period, in a room blocked from students’ view with a chalkboard in front of the window, the teachers watched the second Tower fall. And then I had to go back to a classroom and maintain some sense of normalcy. My own life experiences had taught me to maintain much when it felt like the world was
falling apart. But I felt so inadequate, so feeble in the face of this day. I was supposed to be the teacher, the adult, the one in charge. Don’t ever let anyone convince you that
students are stupid or clueless. Ever. They knew all along. And as they should have, they asked and asked and asked.
In a parochial school, we had a chapel/assembly at the end of the day. But even there, students didn’t get answers. They just were told, “Wait until you get home. You won’t believe it.”
That night, a teacher colleague of mine, brought me to eat with her family at Famous Dave’s. I remember we sat there, stunned, not sure what to say, but in a strange sense of community with each other. Knowing what had happened and just being there together were what felt most important. I don’t know if I ever told her what that meant to me.
To be together helped me. Away from family and not knowing about the safety of my brother thousands of miles away, together was good enough.
It’s what I believe today is so important about teaching and learning and writing. Sometimes, there are no answers. Sometimes, there are only questions. A classroom should be a place where these questions can be asked, no matter if an answer is possible. That day, 1o years ago, having to be so inauthentic with my students, created in me a desire for honest living and teaching. Today, every day I spend in a classroom, I work towards honesty and authenticity, no matter how overwhelming it is.
To me, that’s what this all is about. This living, this teaching, this writing. So many students tell me that they read stories to escape and I wonder about that idea all the time. To me, writing and teaching should bring about honest interactions between people, that because I read this, I understand this about my life now. Because I teach this, I can share this with students. Because I’ve learned this, I can now make sense of this.
How else do I deal with, move alongside and dwell in the midst of what I feel in my heart today, reliving, revisiting, remembering?
What’s most important is that we are in this together, whatever this together means for you.
For me, I cannot help but remember those middle schoolers from Trinity who were honest and authentic and so meaningful to my life, especially following that Tuesday in 2001. I remember especially being together with them.
We might not like each other in our togetherness. We might have issues with each other in our togetherness. We may have problems communicating how we feel in our togetherness. But there is an honesty in the dwelling together, no matter the ease or confusion or sadness
The fact that we’re together should mean something, that this community continues, writing, learning and living because the togetherness reminds us we are not alone.
It’s what 9/11 teaches me still.
Honest living with whatever life brings us
Dwelling with others in the midst of difference and chaos and questions
And recognizing that a community together can mean, do, and live much.









